This user absolutely insists that when a chloride ion is present in water (for example, when NaCl dissolves in water) that ClX− ion is ionically bound to the hydrogen atom:
?noredirect=1#comment55324_34449
I then insist that this would form HX2OCl, but that's impossible due to the lack of valence electrons of H:
?noredirect=1#comment55386_34449
Who is right?